Restoring Law and Order in the District of Columbia
President Trump issued a memorandum ordering the mobilization of the District of Columbia National Guard to address a perceived increase in violent crime in Washington, D.C. The memorandum cites specific instances of violent crime, including murders and assaults near the White House and other government buildings, as justification for the action.
The President directs the Secretary of Defense to mobilize the Guard and coordinate with state governors to deploy additional National Guard personnel, if required.
The memorandum states that the National Guard’s deployment will continue until law and order are restored.
Arguments For
Intended Benefit: Enhancing public safety and restoring order in Washington, D.C. by addressing a perceived surge in violent crime.
Evidence Cited: The memorandum cites specific violent crimes, including the murder of embassy staffers and a Congressional intern, to justify the action. It also points to the high violent crime rate in D.C. as grounds for intervention.
Implementation Method: Mobilizing the D.C. National Guard and authorizing the use of additional National Guard members from other states, if deemed necessary.
Legal/Historical Basis: The President asserts the authority to act under the Constitution and laws of the United States and the District of Columbia as Commander in Chief of the D.C. National Guard.
Arguments Against
Potential Impacts: Potential for mission creep, excessive force by National Guard troops, and infringement on civil liberties. The long-term effectiveness of deploying the National Guard to combat crime is debatable.
Implementation Challenges: Coordinating with multiple state governors for National Guard deployments, logistical burdens, and potential for tension between federal and local authorities. Funding required and its impact on other federal priorities.
Alternative Approaches: Increased funding for local law enforcement, community policing programs, addressing root causes of crime, improving crime prevention strategies, and investing in social services.
Unintended Effects: Erosion of trust in law enforcement, potential for escalation of conflict, increased militarization of policing, further strain on intergovernmental relations.
Memorandum for THE SECRETARY OF DEFENSE
SUBJECT: Restoring Law and Order in the District of Columbia
This is the heading of the Presidential Memorandum.
It identifies the recipient (Secretary of Defense) and the subject matter (restoring law and order in Washington, D.C.).
Section 1. Background. As President of the United States and Commander in Chief of the District of Columbia National Guard, it is my solemn duty to protect law-abiding citizens from the destructive forces of criminal activity. That obligation applies with special force in our Nation’s capital, where, as Commander in Chief of the District of Columbia National Guard, I must also ensure that all citizens can avail themselves of the right to interact with their elected representatives, and that the Federal Government can properly function, without fear of being subjected to violent, menacing street crime.
The local government of the District of Columbia has lost control of public order and safety in the city, as evidenced by the two embassy staffers who were murdered in May, the Congressional intern who was fatally shot a short distance from the White House in June, and the Administration staffer who was mercilessly beaten by a violent mob days ago. Citizens, tourists, and staff alike are unable to live peacefully in the Nation’s capital, which is under siege from violent crime. It is a point of national disgrace that Washington, D.C., has a violent crime rate that is higher than some of the most dangerous places in the world. It is my duty to our citizens and Federal workers to secure the safety and the peaceful functioning of our Nation, the Federal Government, and our city.
This section provides the context for the memorandum.
It establishes the President's authority and responsibility to ensure public safety in Washington, D.C., particularly near federal buildings.
Specific examples of violent crime are presented to illustrate the urgency of the situation.
The high crime rate relative to other locations is also highlighted.
Sec. 2. Mobilizing the District of Columbia National Guard. Pursuant to my authority under the Constitution and laws of the United States and the District of Columbia, I direct the Secretary of Defense to mobilize the District of Columbia National Guard and order members to active service, in such numbers as he deems necessary, to address the epidemic of crime in our Nation’s capital. The mobilization and duration of duty shall remain in effect until I determine that conditions of law and order have been restored in the District of Columbia. Further, I direct the Secretary of Defense to coordinate with State Governors and authorize the orders of any additional members of the National Guard to active service, as he deems necessary and appropriate, to augment this mission.
This section outlines the President's directive. The Secretary of Defense is ordered to mobilize the District of Columbia National Guard to combat the rising crime. The mobilization will continue until the President deems the situation resolved.
The Secretary of Defense is also authorized to coordinate with state governors to potentially utilize additional National Guard personnel from other states.
Sec. 3. General Provisions. This memorandum is not intended to, and does not, create any right or benefit, substantive or procedural, enforceable at law or in equity by any party against the United States, its departments, agencies, or entities, its officers, employees, or agents, or any other person.
This section contains a standard legal disclaimer, stating that the memorandum does not create any legally enforceable rights.
DONALD J. TRUMP
This is the signature of the President.
Related
Adjusting Imports of Pharmaceuticals and Pharmaceutical Ingredients into the United States
* The President imposed a 100% <em>ad valorem</em> tariff on specified imported patented pharmaceuticals and APIs under Section 232 authority, while setting lower tariff rates for companies committing to domestic onshoring and directing negotiation efforts to secure supply chains.
Read MoreStrengthening Actions Taken to Adjust Imports of Aluminum, Steel, and Copper Into the United States
The President strengthened existing Section 232 tariffs on aluminum, steel, and copper imports by applying duties to the full customs value, setting new specific *ad valorem* rates, offering preferential rates, and altering the process for adding derivative articles.
Read MoreEnsuring Citizenship Verification and Integrity in Federal Elections
* The President directed federal agencies to create and transmit state-specific lists of eligible citizen voters, ordered the USPS to institute tracking requirements for mail-in ballots, and prioritized investigations into election fraud involving ballots sent to non-citizens.
Read MorePaying Our Great Transportation Security Administration Officers and Employees
* The President directed the heads of DHS and OMB to use existing funds to pay TSA employees who were not receiving pay due to the Department of Homeland Security shutdown.
Read More